Fair Play Homes with Two Stories

Welcome to Fair Play, a charming town nestled in the heart of Oconee County, South Carolina. Known for its tranquil surroundings and friendly community, Fair Play offers a peaceful retreat for those looking to escape the hustle and bustle of city life.

If you're in the market for a home with two stories, Fair Play has a variety of options to choose from. Whether you're looking for a cozy two-story cottage or a spacious family home, you'll find the perfect property to suit your needs in this picturesque town.

Imagine waking up to the sound of birds chirping and the gentle rustling of leaves in the breeze. With its scenic views and close-knit atmosphere, Fair Play is the ideal place to put down roots and create lasting memories with your loved ones.

From outdoor recreational activities to local shops and restaurants, Fair Play has something for everyone to enjoy. Whether you're exploring the nearby hiking trails or savoring a delicious meal at a quaint cafe, you'll quickly fall in love with the laid-back lifestyle that this town has to offer.

Don't miss out on the opportunity to make Fair Play your new home. Contact us today to learn more about the available homes with two stories in this charming community.

Newest Fair Play Homes with Two Stories

$359,900

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 20304323 MLS

Life feels better at 265 Capps Road, your lakefront escape where good times unfold. Tucked along the shores of Lake Hartwell, this beloved retreat is ready for new owners to create a lifetime of memories. With two bedrooms and a full bath on the main level plus a spacious sleeping loft upstairs, there's room for everyone to spread out and unwind. The heart of the home is a vaulted living room anchored by a stacked stone fireplace, flowing into a large kitchen with bar seating, made for gathering. Step out to the generous screened porch complete with TV, ample seating, and a bar, and let the lake do the rest. Whether you're celebrating, relaxing, or simply soaking in the view, this porch will become your favorite place to be. This home is being sold fully furnished and is already set up to sleep 10+, making it a true turnkey retreat from day one. Underneath you'll find a golf cart garage and storage for all your lake toys. This property is ideally suited for buyers seeking the lakefront lifestyle through swimming, kayaking, and the pure enjoyment of being on the water. A neighborhood boat ramp keeps the lake fully accessible without the added cost and maintenance of a private dock. The lot sits in a green zone right on the water, and the cove features a natural waterfall that has to be seen to be appreciated. There is room on the property to park your boat and trailer. Come see why 265 Capps Road feels like everywhere else you've ever been, only better.

265 Capps Road, Fair Play

$899,000

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 20304202 MLS

This Lake Hartwell home sits on a double lot 2+acres, has private covered dock in place, and lots of recent upgrades! Gated community filled with executive homes. Close to I-85 and EV charging station off exit 4 quickly gets you on the interstate to Atlanta, Anderson, or Greenville.. When you pull in, you will appreciate the privacy, incredible amount of parking, and concrete paths around the sides and down to the lake! Entire house, driveway, decks, porches and dock freshly pressure washed. Open concept floor plan with cathedral ceilings, fully appointed kitchen, 4 Beds and 4 Full Baths. Primary Suite on main has deck access features double sinks, garden tub, separate shower, and 2 walk-in closets. New roof 2023, New paint throughout, New upgraded carpet in main level bedrooms, refinished hardwoods, gutters upgraded to Leaf Filter system with transferrable warranty. Synthetic no maintenance expansive decking in rear wraps around sides of main level. Check out the walkout basement! All LVP, Large open area for entertaining, another bed and bath, flex rooms, large landing area. Heading out back basement level is a spacious covered patio and stairs to top deck. Head down the concrete walkways to the lake a fire-pit awaits. You're ready to host relaxing nights, make memories, tell stories, roast marshmallows, and soak in your private tranquil lake oasis. Additional storage building also conveys for lawn equipment or additional storage. Home comes with the appliances, air-hockey, extra basement fridge, TV's, Camera system, Dartboard, and everything else you see inside. Kayaks and everything at the dock is also yours with purchase. Current water levels are historically low. Dock can be moved out quite a bit according to the C.O.E. as water levels rise. Quick boat ride to Tilly's Tiki hut for live music food and drinks by way of water. Harbor Light Marina if you need to gas, ice, or lake supples white boating. Property taxes currently showing at the investor (Non-Owner occupant rate). Primary home residents pay significantly less. Check the Oconee County Tax estimator for accurate property taxes to reflect your planned use.

104 Gates Cove Drive, Fair Play

$539,900

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 20303129 MLS

Come home to 1111 Bay Drive in Treasure Bay, a like-new 2023 Craftsman-style home near Lake Hartwell, offering modern comfort, privacy, and quick access to lake life. This 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home features approximately 2,648 square feet on a private 0.65-acre lot with wooded views, fenced back yard, abundant wildlife, and no rear neighbors. Inside, the open-concept layout includes luxury vinyl plank flooring, 9-foot ceilings, an electric fireplace, a formal dining room, a breakfast area, a spacious laundry room, and a beautifully finished kitchen with quartz countertops, soft-close cabinetry, stainless appliances, walk-in pantry, farmhouse sink, and custom wet bar/butler’s pantry. The main-level primary suite offers convenience, privacy, and a spacious walk-in closet. Upper level features three secondary bedrooms and a full bath. The upstairs landing area can also be used as additional living space/rec room. Enjoy outdoor living from the covered back patio, plus an oversized two-car garage and level concrete driveway. Located in Fair Play, SC, minutes from I-85, the Georgia line, and less than 2 miles from two public Lake Hartwell boat ramps. A rare blend of newer construction, lake access, privacy, and convenience.

1111 Bay Drive, Fair Play

$489,999

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 20302209 MLS

Wake up to the sound of a gently flowing creek, sip your morning coffee overlooking Lake Hartwell, and end each day with breathtaking sunsets from your expansive back deck. At 160 Tugaloo Shores Road, life moves at a different pace. Set on 3.34 private acres with no HOA and no restrictions, this charming waterfront cabin offers a rare opportunity to enjoy the peace and freedom that's becoming increasingly difficult to find. With 150 feet of natural shoreline and year-round lake views, you'll enjoy the beauty of waterfront living while surrounded by mature trees and abundant privacy. Inside, the warm and inviting floor plan is designed for gathering. The spacious eat-in kitchen opens to the living area, making it easy to entertain family and friends after a day on the lake or around the fire pit. The main-level primary suite provides a private retreat with an attached full bath, while two additional bedrooms and a second full bathroom offer comfortable accommodations for guests. Recent improvements include a newly replaced upstairs HVAC system, providing added comfort and peace of mind, and all kitchen and laundry appliances convey with the home for added convenience. Upstairs, the versatile loft creates the perfect space for movie nights, a home office, bunk room, or game room. A fourth bedroom and half bath make it easy to host family and friends all year long. Outside is where this property truly shines. Spend your afternoons relaxing on the oversized decks, listening to the nearby creek, watching wildlife, and taking in uninterrupted views of Lake Hartwell. A private lower deck is already outfitted for a hot tub, creating the perfect place to unwind after a day outdoors. The non-dockable shoreline preserves the natural beauty of the property, creating an exceptionally peaceful setting that's perfect for kayaking, fishing from the bank, or simply enjoying the water without the congestion of heavy boat traffic. Whether you're looking for a full-time home, a weekend getaway, or an investment opportunity, this unrestricted Fair Play retreat offers the freedom to make it your own. Here, life is measured by peaceful mornings overlooking the lake, evenings around the fire, and time well spent with the people who matter most. It's more than a home. It's the Lake Hartwell lifestyle.

160 Tugaloo Shores Road, Fair Play

$524,900

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 20301874 MLS

Discover unparalleled modern living in this brand-new, move-in ready residence, where every detail has been meticulously crafted for comfort and style. This exceptional 4-bedroom, 3.5-bathroom home spans 2765 square feet, offering expansive living spaces on a generous 1.24-acre lot. Enjoy the seamless flow of LVT flooring throughout, complemented by custom cabinetry and vanities, and elegant quartz countertops that elevate the aesthetic. The primary suite features a luxurious walk-in shower with a glass door, while an additional tub upstairs provides a relaxing retreat. Dedicated office space offers an ideal environment for productivity, and a massive bonus room with its own bathroom presents endless possibilities for recreation or guest accommodation. The exterior boasts durable composite siding, a concrete driveway, and inviting covered front and back porches with sophisticated tongue and groove ceilings. Modern wire-brushed aluminum railings add a touch of contemporary elegance both inside and out. With huge European windows, the interior is bathed in an abundance of natural light, creating a bright and airy atmosphere. The kitchen is equipped with brand-new GE appliances, reflecting the home's commitment to quality. Located just 3.6 miles from a Lake Hartwell boat ramp, this property offers the unique advantage of ample space to park your camper or boat, embodying the best of country living with convenient lake access. This is an incredible opportunity to secure a new construction home in a serene setting, eliminating the wait for building and providing immediate enjoyment with no HOA. Come take a look today.

114 Brambleberry Trail, Fair Play

$819,900

4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 20301410 MLS

Experience the Lake Hartwell lifestyle with the opportunity to enjoy a boat slip through the community dock program. The current annual lease has already been paid, allowing the new owner to enjoy the remainder of the lease term and convenient access to boating, fishing, and recreation on the lake. Welcome to elevated lake living in the highly sought-after private community of Parkview South on Lake Hartwell. Perfectly positioned just one street from the water, this custom-designed home offers the kind of lifestyle people dream about, with a deeded boat slip within walking distance and seasonal lake views that create the perfect backdrop for everyday living. With approximately 2600 square feet, this thoughtfully designed home features 4 bedrooms, 3.5 bathrooms, and a versatile flex room, all curated with a warm modern style that feels both luxurious and inviting. From the moment you step inside, the soaring open-to-second-floor living room immediately captures your attention, with natural light pouring through the home and creating an airy, connected atmosphere perfect for gathering and entertaining. The kitchen was designed to truly be the heart of the home, featuring quartz countertops, premium Café appliances, custom finishes, and timeless details that blend beauty with functionality. The open layout flows seamlessly into the dining and living spaces, making the home feel ideal for hosting family and friends while still feeling comfortable for everyday life. The main-level owner’s suite offers a peaceful retreat with a spa-inspired bathroom featuring beautiful tilework, curated lighting, refined finishes, and an elevated design throughout. Every bathroom in the home was intentionally designed with warmth, texture, and sophistication in mind. Thoughtful details continue throughout the home, including a functional mud room, spacious laundry room, and even a built-in dog shower because every detail here was created with lifestyle in mind. The extended driveway offers additional space for boat parking, making lake days effortless and convenient. Outside, the experience only gets better. Rustic natural landscaping blends beautifully with the surroundings, incorporating stone and organic textures that feel timeless and relaxing. Above the home, a perfectly positioned fire pit creates an incredible setting to unwind under the stars while enjoying peaceful lake views through the trees. Whether you’re spending summer days on the water, enjoying coffee on the screened porch, hosting friends around the fire pit, or simply taking in the warmth and light this home offers, every space was intentionally designed to be experienced. This is more than just a home. It is a lifestyle centered around connection, comfort, nature, and unforgettable memories on Lake Hartwell.

119 S Shore Drive, Fair Play

$610,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 20301401 MLS

Lake season is here and this home is the perfect way to enjoy Lake Hartwell. This 4 bedroom/2 bath home features beautiful lake views, plenty of living space, and an updated and refreshed interior! When walking in the front door your eye is immediately drawn to the lake views! The first floor features a large kitchen area with island for extra seating and serving space. Tons of counter and cabinet space with all appliances. An open floor plan so there is no disconnect from family and friends and abundant lake views. Upstairs you’ll find 3 additional bedrooms, a Bathroom, and a large bonus/loft. And, of course those great lake views! Enjoy evenings on your screened in, wrap around porch or hanging out on your own private, covered dock. There is ample space for enjoying the lake and land and an outdoor shower to clean off or clean the fish! The property includes an additional lot giving you added lake frontage as well as space! Whether you choose to build a second home or leave the land undeveloped the choice is yours. There is also plenty of parking space which means you can invite everyone! Enjoy this lake season in your own home!

104 Lakehill Drive, Fair Play

$360,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 20300283 MLS

ESCAPE to the LAKE, bring your boat and enjoy the community DOCK with BOAT SLIP included!! CONVENIENCE and EASY ACCESS to I-85 with the BENEFITS of Lake Hartwell while also enjoying the community pool and clubhouse. The TERRACE level offers a private SECOND living space IDEAL for an in-law suite, guests, or a teenager’s retreat complete with its own kitchen, living area, and laundry. ENJOY both an interior entrance and a SEPARATE private exterior entrance for added CONVENIENCE and FLEXIBILITY. START your mornings with a cup of coffee on the WELCOMING front porch, then STEP INSIDE to a warm and INVITING living space. WANDER through and IMAGINE GATHERING here with friends and family in your DREAM kitchen perfect for entertaining! Spacious laundry and mud room leads to the oversized two car garage. RETREAT to your owner’s suite with spacious walk-in closet and ensuite. RELAX on your back deck, ENJOY the large FENCED yard, and UNWIND after a long day. Whether you're looking for your FIRST HOME, a SERENE GETAWAY, or low maintenance RIGHT-SIZING. This property comes with boat parking at the dock, located behind the Clubhouse and Community pool, and offers the lifestyle you've been dreaming of! This PRIME location is easy access to I-85 and scenic Highway 11, close to several local eateries, golf course, Seneca, Anderson, Clemson, Lavonia, Hartwell, and just 45 minutes to Greenville. START LIVING YOUR BEST LIFE! **If Buyer uses preferred Lender, Mary Ripley at Integrity Home Lending, they will receive up to $1800 in paid closing costs at closing.

281 Cherokee Drive, Fair Play

$1,285,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 20299882 MLS

LOCATION, LOCATION ! A custom forever home on Lake Hartwell. Nestled in the peaceful Moonlight Bay, just minutes from I85 off Highway 11. Convenient to Anderson, Seneca, Greenville airport and more. This custom built home sits on 1.19 wooded acres. Follow the 200 ft. concrete drive to view the home's quality exterior, stately hip roof, brick stone and hardy plank siding framed by blooming perennials. Designed to be the perfect forever home, built with Anderson Casement windows and sliders, and finished with 9, -10, - and 11 foot ceilings that bring light and space to every room. The house features a wired sound system with four zones and seven Klipsch speaker. The oversized 2 car garage, lots of storage complete with lake view. The covered front door opens to an elegant great room, where 11ft ceiling, crown molding, and 6 broad windows frame the view of lake Hartwell. A stacked stone gas fireplace rises from floor to ceiling, commanding yet welcoming. Tucked near the front door, the home office, a place for inspiration. A desk, storage, hutches and file cabinets are ready for work. The view from the office is full of seasonal blooming bulbs, shrubs and trees. The custom maple kitchen cabinets feature Granite counters, and lots of storage. (19 drawers). Dishwasher is thoughtfully designed (raised height) to provide you with comfort and ease when loading and unloading. All appliances convey. The primary bedroom with tray ceilings, create the perfect restful escape. The room is anchored with a slat wall behind the bed. Primary boasts 3 closets, one is a large walk in. The spa inspired bath has double vanities, custom cabinetry and a large walk in shower. Primary bedroom also has a beautiful lake view and access to the screen porch. The sunroom provides the perfect place to enjoy your morning brew, curl up with a book or keep the chef company while they create. The downstairs offers a little something for everyone, the spacious rec room, gym, two bedrooms another full bathroom a "bunk room" and an incredible workshop, "man cave". There is also a covered patio area, one more place to sit and enjoy the tranquility and to top it all off a great "outdoor shower". The concrete path leads you to your covered slip dock and 100' of shoreline. Having both electric and water at your dock, it is the perfect place to hang out and enjoy the day. The dock is all aluminum and Ipe (Brazilian hardwood) to provide you years of maintenance free boat storage. Across the cove is federal land, untouched, undockable, unspoiled. No neighbor, just the beauty of the cove, the shimmer of the sunlight on the water and the joy of knowing this view will never change. Every detail of this home was well planned, and speaks to care, comfort and craftsmanship. It is not a place to live, it is a place to love. Welcome home.

402 Boaters Row, Fair Play

$849,643

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 20287686 MLS

Welcome to 109 South Shore Drive, a beautifully appointed 4-bedroom, 3-bath ranch home in the coveted Parkview community on Lake Hartwell. Thoughtfully designed and meticulously maintained, this residence offers approximately 3,300 finished square feet of elevated lake living on a private .95-acre parcel comprised of three combined lots. Inside, you’ll find a refined open-concept layout anchored by a spacious great room with soaring ceilings, expansive windows, and an effortless flow to the surrounding living areas. The heart of the home is its exceptional chef’s kitchen, equipped with a Wolf six-burner gas range, Cove dishwasher, built-in coffee bar, and generous butler’s pantry. Sleek countertops, custom cabinetry, and elegant finishes blend functionality with beauty, creating the perfect space for entertaining or everyday living. The main level features three bedrooms, including the serene primary suite with its own private porch, an ideal setting for morning coffee or peaceful evening views. Two additional guest suites provide comfort and privacy for family and visitors, with one guest suite enjoying exclusive access to a private porch overlooking the beautifully landscaped grounds and lake. The terrace level adds even more flexible living space with a fourth bedroom, a custom wine cellar, and a walkout to a covered outdoor living area enhanced by an under-decking system that allows for year-round enjoyment, rain or shine. Outdoors, the park-like grounds are a true showpiece. A beautifully manicured lawn is framed by mature trees, flowering shrubs, and thoughtfully designed landscaping that invites both relaxation and recreation. Whether you’re entertaining under the stars or enjoying quiet moments in nature, the setting is equally inspiring. For the boating enthusiast, one assigned boat slip is located at the end of the nearby community dock, just a short, paved stroll from the home. The slips are situated in consistently deep water, ensuring easy access and year-round enjoyment on Lake Hartwell. An additional .58 acre lot is available adjacent to this property for a total of 1.53 acres. Additional highlights include a detached workshop with power and water, ideal for hobbies or potential guest quarters, and a fully equipped greenhouse with water and power, making this property a true gardener’s dream. Ideally located just off I-85, 109 South Shore Drive is only 45 minutes to Greenville and under two hours to downtown Atlanta, offering the perfect blend of peaceful lake living with convenient access to city amenities. This is Lake Hartwell living at its finest, private, polished, and perfectly positioned.

109 S Shore Drive, Fair Play

Start Your Search

The Listings data contained on this website comes from various participants of The Multiple Listing Service of Greenville, SC, Inc. Internet Data Exchange. IDX information is provided exclusively for consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. The properties displayed may not be all the properties available. All information provided is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. © 2026 Greater Greenville Association of REALTORS®. All Rights Reserved. Last Updated